Why should you audit your engineering firm's lump sum pricing before a buyer does?
Why lump sum work hides the earnings a buyer will pay for, and how to run the pricing audit on your engineering firm's portfolio yourself.

Because the earnings a buyer will pay for are the earnings a buyer can prove, and lump sum work is where what you report and what a buyer can prove come apart. Run that audit yourself and you get to fix what it finds. Let the buyer run it first and the finding becomes the price.
What does a buyer's audit actually look at?
Not fraud. Repeatability.
The buyer is asking one question across your whole portfolio: which of these jobs made money, and would they make it again at the same fee? A job that made money because the schedule was kind or the scope held still is not the same asset as a job that makes money every time you bid that work.
Your books answer at the firm level. A buyer wants the answer at the project level, then sorted by project type, client type and the person who estimated it.
The request is usually simple, and that is what makes it dangerous. For each lump sum job: the fee, the hours budgeted, the hours spent, and any change order that moved the fee. Most firms produce the fee and the budgeted hours the same afternoon. The hours spent is where the file gets thin.
Why does lump sum work hide the answer?
Hourly work is self correcting. If you estimate a job wrong, next month's invoice is smaller and the client feels it. The market corrects you in public, job by job, week by week.
Lump sum does not work that way. The fee is set at the price you bid and it stays there. A bad estimate never shows up as a lower rate. It shows up as hours nobody billed.
Here is the arithmetic on one job, priced the way most of us price them:
- Fee: $300,000.
- Estimated hours: 2,000, at $120 an hour loaded cost, or $240,000.
- Planned gross profit: $60,000.
- Actual hours: 2,600, or $312,000 of cost.
- Result: a $12,000 loss on a job whose invoice looked healthy.
The person who estimated that job was not dishonest. On lump sum work the estimate is the price and the hours arrive later. Nothing in the workflow forces the two back together unless someone goes looking.
One job is a lesson. A portfolio of them is a pricing model, and a buyer reads a pricing model differently than you read a project.
What does the audit change about the multiple?
A multiple is applied to a base a buyer accepts, not to the base you report. If part of your gross profit came from work priced below what it cost to deliver, the buyer does not argue about it. It comes out of the base.
That is the whole of it: you bought at ten, the audit says three. The gap is not a buyer being difficult with you. It is the difference between earnings you recorded and earnings a buyer will underwrite after reading the timesheets behind your lump sum jobs.
An audit does not find that your firm is bad. It finds which parts of your firm a buyer will pay for and which parts they will discount, and those are rarely the parts you would have guessed.
This is also why growth by acquisition without fixing delivery does not work. Buying another firm adds revenue on top of a model that will not survive the buyer's audit. A larger base makes the correction larger, not smaller. The cheapest exit protection an owner or a sponsor has is a lump sum pricing audit run across the portfolio before anyone else runs it.
How do you run the audit yourself?
You need the fee, the hours and the loaded cost, per job. Nothing else.
- Pull every lump sum job in a defined window, closed and running, including the ones that felt good.
- Rebuild actual hours against the fee. Load the cost per hour, not salary, or the numbers flatter you.
- Sort by estimator, project type, client type and scope. The pattern matters more than the individual job, because it tells you which kind of work you cannot price, not which job went wrong.
- Separate repeatable margin from luck. A job that made money because the scope grew is not evidence that the price was right.
- Decide by group, not by job: reprice it, cap the scope, change how it is delivered, or stop bidding it.
What do you do with the answer?
Three piles. Work you should stop bidding. Work you price wrong and can reprice. Work you price right and should be selling harder than you do.
The first pile is the one that pays for the audit. A firm that stops bidding the work it cannot deliver profitably does not shrink. It gets faster, it gets calmer, and the earnings left on the books are the ones a buyer will pay for.
There is a second use for the audit. Once you know which jobs carry the margin, the conversation with a buyer starts from evidence instead of a projection, and evidence is cheaper to defend.
My firm has run 525+ projects since 2017, and the argument here comes straight out of that run. The jobs that hurt were never the ones we expected.
What to do next week
Pick the window. Last twelve months of lump sum work, closed jobs only. Pull the fees and the actual hours, and load the cost honestly, including the hours your senior people spent.
Then take the ten worst and ask one question about each: did we price it wrong, or did we deliver it wrong? The two have different fixes, and lump sum work punishes both.
If a few of those ten come from the same kind of job, you already have your answer and it is not about the estimate. It is about what you bid. Fix that before you buy anything else, and before anyone else reads your books.
From the book Engineer Your Freedom
Michael Groselle, P.E., is the founder of Modern Engineering Solutions, a multi-state water and wastewater engineering firm. He left salaried engineering in 2017 and built the firm from one resignation letter and zero clients to more than $2M in annual revenue, with a team of 37 and 525+ completed projects.
Sold on Amazon. Prefer the Kindle edition? Buy it on Amazon ($9.99).